Right to Information for All ?

26,644

Right to information act is about to be hammered out in the National Assembly of Bhutan.

Deliberation in the house is making everyone to think of the right to access to information hitherto not in practice in Bhutan’s history. Some are thinking that constitution has granted that right, so a separate act is not required, while some ague that it is not a good time to introduce the bill. Sangay Khandu, the NC member from Gasa is the man behind putting the idea of RTI to the floor.

It is argued that the engine of RTI is fired some seven years ago, but it was held for consultation and public feedback. Whether feed back from all sectors is sought or not, information seeking by the public on the matters of their concern used to be largely ignored. The general public in Bhutan has largely been unaware of the right to information and thus denied by the government.

Opposition party members in the National Assembly are not very supportive of the bill and are relegating to the fear of being paralyzed if the act is to be implemented. One MP, Dorji Wangdi, even do not see the need to have an act in place, which is enshrined in the constitution under fundamental rights. “Having a separate law will only weaken the strength of this fundamental right” was his argument.

Although the former DPT government reiterated its commitment to introduce the bill in 2012, it did not happen or there were other matters before the government to finalize. It was simply a reluctance by the former government to introduce the bill which actually had its origination well back in 2006. Information seeking from the ministers and high-profile officers in bureaucracy by the press in those times and even  after first election was not easy. There were instances when reporters were denied the information with threat, verbal abuse or not at all entertained.

The willingness to introduce the right to information bill by DPT government and the readiness of PDP government to table it in the house is a symbol of progress towards ensuring transparency in service delivery. But the bill is tabled only after having it researched by a group of Columbia university students under Prof. Anya Schiffrin who happened to be the better half of Nobel laureate Prof. Joseph Stiglitz. Prof. Stiglitz had also visited Bhutan in 2010 to give approval to the Bhutan model of quantifying GNH.

The interesting thing will be to see if this group of researchers in New York actually knew the way RTI will be understood and enforced in Bhutan that many have not seen. And in Bhutan, whether it will be comfortable for all to showcase that foreign-brewed information act and be obliged to it.

A reporter’s story from field

Arjun PradhanThe people in the community always thought that there should be equal love and respect form each side. If one is educated he or she must educate the own community on various aspects of life. Let me cite a popular saying in Nepali that thematically translated as “if a woman is educated, her whole family is educated”.  Now that is not the case, but opposite to this norm. Today the educated fellows care more about their own life style and take community role as hostile to their daily business.

My point of view is: the Bhutanese community is educated and has entered a phase of economic empowerment with improved life style after resettlement in the third countries.  Nevertheless, those uneducated and elderly who did not go to school back in their country, are still less privileged.  They are still living with depression, frustration, trauma of being separated from their possession culminating to bring a feeling of finishing one’s life.

If we allow ourselves to flash back on our life in camp, we shall realize how far we have traveled.  We lived under penury, very basic need of food and shelter not enough for the daily subsistence, poor health and other human needs too.  For making a decent living, we often crossed the boundary of refugee camps and went out to earn some money. The result, for sure, would be with punishment like suspending of ration, deregistration from the camp record, or sometimes false allegation and police custody. With the cheap labor force, local area got developed. Refugees got lower wage rates with lot of harassment and abuse by the local people.

After all, the local area initially with small shanty towns, developed to lively business hubs.

Meanwhile, group fighting and scuffles arose time and again between Bhotangey and local Nepalese. Bhotangey is a derogatory identity to all camp people. When such issues arise, it is always the camp people to lose for they are not considered equal to the local Nepali citizens in terms of getting their fundamental rights protected.

There are painful moments. No one is aware about the rights and duties. All are under supervision of the Nepalese government and UNHCR. So, everybody has to take permit while going out of the camps. Getting back to camps, the people often faced false charges of violating the camp rules, and this is mostly applied to the youths. To some young people whose parents did not live in camps, the experience is more bitter. Often they fell victims to unlawful detention, engaged in gang fight, rape, illicit drug use and other felony leading to prison cells. With the increase of material need and lust for modern goods, more youths fell into criminal cases. Burglary, theft, arson and girl trafficking emerged to be common phenomena in camps.

To curb these growing social problems and to do away with prevailing social evils, literary activities were started that also generated awareness on such issues. They published newspapers, magazines and bulletins to post in school wall magazine and public bulletin boards. That helped young minds to engage in creative activities rather than making their minds a devil’s workshop. Effective was the role played by Children Forum and Youth Forum. Awareness on human rights, domestic violence, abuse, trafficking and others through street drama, conference, meeting, and doors to doors program were conducted.

After all, empowering youth with creative programs with meager  amount of funds did not bring a desired result. Students started dropping out of schools, some  joined the wave of political activities brought by leftist ideologues and  influenced by the success of people’s war in Nepal. It was a movement for repatriation.

Stories of camp life came to news sites and Nepalese news media. Follow up stories and features were published in newspapers attracted refugee students and general people. Every hut was a news source then. The Bhutanese themselves started the news site and published monthly bulletins, first by the political and human rights groups, and later by more media trained non-partisan youths.

After Bhutan News Service was established in 2004, it became a strong and continuous source of information for the camp people. It also acted as advocacy group on behalf of the refugees.   A number of youths served voluntarily and worked full time to get news from different organizations working in the refugee camp. However, it was not a easy task for the young volunteers to collect news from the tricky officials. A lot of hurdles came on the way in the making of a good news for Bhutan News Service. 

Later, the news reported in BNS became a source of information for other local media like FM and newspapers in Jhapa and Morang district of Nepal. Human rights groups, camp management committee, UNHCR, government of Nepal and even international bodies became the consumer of BNS news. The refugee leaders used BNS to inform the public about their plans and programs through their press release. BNS wrote news stories advocating on social issues, women empowerment and repatriation movement with the help of the camp based volunteers and support of organizations involved.

As a team of young professionals, we are always learning to make the information flow a better way with impacts of positive change. So, any information that produces a volley of negative remarks from the community is not enjoyed by BNS. But, the focus is community transformation towards better life with educational and occupational attainment.  From news making within the periphery of refugee camp, BNS has come a long way now to report on matters of international concern in Diaspora as well as in Bhutan. We believe, we do not have enemies to fight nor any good friends to celebrate. Therefore, BNS is always for the community wherever it is.

Organizer kisses regional volleyball trophy

26,644

Beating Armed Police Force (APF) in the final battle Team A from the organizing team bagged the tittle of eastern regional volleyball tournament, Wednesday.

APF player attempts to smash the ball as his opponent tries to restrict (Picture: Dikesh Lama/BNS)
APF player attempts to smash the ball as his opponent tries to restrict (Picture: Dikesh Lama/BNS)

APF team defeated the Team A in the first match pushing the latter behind 20 score, while other tournaments sat at 25-20, 28-25, 25-22 and 23-25 against APF.

The Team A received cash award of Rs 41,000 while APF received Rs 31,000 besides trophies, and certificates.

The organizer also honored over a dozen of volunteers including journalist Dikesh Lama, and Carista Nepal Field Director Father Amajraj among others, according to TR Rai.

Chairman of the Eastern Regional Volley Association, Visho Dhimal, witnessed the tournament as Chief Guest. Deputy Superintendent of Police (DSP) Ramesh Shrestha from the Pathibhara Battalion, and representatives from various aid-agencies were also present as guests, informed organizer.

Louisville annual sports, Cleveland soccer conclude

26,644

As a continuation of annual sports event, Bhutanese resettled in Louisville enjoyed cheering up for the small-size football match on 14 and 15 September played at a church ground in Bardstown forest apartment area.

Altogether ten teams, including one from Nepalese community,  played the matches that  went for two days. On 14th September, first and second round of matches were finalized while on 15th September the semi-final and final matches were played.

The second day was more lively as sports events like balloon fighting, hundred meter race to boys and girls, and musical chair for adult females added entertainment to the game. During the recess, music and dance added flavor.

BSK Trophy
BSK Trophy

The final game was played between Rangeland apartment and Maplewood apartment which ended with a penalty shoot out by the Rangeland team that won the trophy.

 The game was played under the judgment of  Amrit Regmi, the US Soccer certified umpire.

Prakash Mainali of Bannon Crossings and Kamal Khanal of Rangeland were declared as most valuable and most disciplined players respectively.

Also in the event of this annual sports organized by Bhutanese Society of Kentucky, ex-players, volunteers, sponsors and social servants were honored.

BSK has been organizing the annual sports to encourage young players and sports fan show their talents, engage in creative activities and boost their morality.

Inter-state soccer in Cleveland

Resettled youths from Cleveland of Ohio held the yet another inter-state soccer tournament that concluded on September 15.

Team members of the Cleveland United (Picture : Jitu Basnet)
Team members of the Cleveland United (Picture courtesy : Jitu Basnet)

The organizing team Cleveland United lifted the winner trophy beating team Scranton 3-0 in the final game played in North Olmsted Soccer field in Cleveland.

The winner and the runner up teams were awarded with the trophy, cash and individual medals, informed organizer.

Dilli Bhatarai of Columbus scored the highest number of goals while Prem Bania from PA Scranton was declared as ‘man of the tournament’.

Purna Khawas and Jitu Basnet judged all the games. Basnet is a US certified soccer referee, who is currently volunteering as the sports secretary of OBCA.

Nandu Poudyal, the lead organizer of the tournament, informed BNS that altogether 15 teams from various neighboring states participated in the tournament.

 

‘Shambhu Rai Nite’ in Thimphu enthrills audience

Shambhu Rai, a legendary folk singer from eastern Nepal, performed live in YDF hall, Thimphu on 14 and 15 September.

Bhutanese girls singing at the event
Bhutanese girls singing at the event

A huge crowd gathered to listen to this legendary singer who touched down to the hearts of Bhutanese music lovers by singing his famous melodies like Timile samjhe ni lakhai chha..., Marera jane chola yo….to which the youths and adults could not resist dancing on the floor during his performance.

Shambhu Rai was invited to Bhutan by Kirat Dharma Samiti, a component of Hindu Dharma Samudaya, Bhutan. The organizing committee comprised of former NC candidates and Thimphu based senior citizens of southern Bhutan.

As a part of fund raising, the tickets were sold for Nu 500 and Nu 300.  According to an audience to the program, who talked to BNS over the phone, the YDF hall was packed with about 3000 people who came from vicinity of Thimphu too.

The informant said, people from all walks of life and ethnicity enjoyed the program that went for two days.

Artists of Sargam Club performing
Artists of Sargam Club performing

Ganesh Ghimirey a member of organizing committee posted photos of the event for which Sangay K Khandu commented; cool nite with Shambu rai…relli enjoyed …thanks to sargam band,,,,and ganesh ba.  

The go-between performance of song and dance was by the artists of Sargam band, a cultural club in Thimphu.

What appealed the fans was Shambhu Rai’s style of presenting the song each with a bit of background for each song and lyrics he chose. “Out of sheer emotion and attachment to the songs, people whistled and applauded with loud noise” said the participant.

The performance attracted NC member from Dagana,  Sonam Dorji, in the first day while Minister of Information and Communication, Dinanath Dhungyel went to listen Shambhu Rai on the second day.

The promo, “Shambu Rai Nite” hung over the main entrance to Thimphu and other pubic places for over a week by which people got information through this canvassing.

Ganesh with singer Rai, and his wife
Ganesh with singer Rai, and his wife

According to this source BNS contacted in Phuentsholing, members of organizing committee donned their gho, while the audiences and the technicians, artists appeared in formal shirt pant, and some could be seen with cultural dress of Lhotshampa, daura suruwal and topi.

 At the end of each show, the fans of Shambhu Rai rushed to get his autograph and queued to talk to him personally.

The sponsors of the live event were SCL Travels, Manpang Enterprise and Semjong Enterprise.

Bhutanese media, except BBS English page on its website, has not published news of the performance.

Shambhu Rai’s modern and folk songs typical of eastern flavor have been long popular among Bhutan’s rural mass.

(Reported with inputs from some of the informants from Bhutan, while pictures used have been taken from Ganesh Ghimirey’s Facebook page).

बेलायती राजदुतलाई शरणार्थीको पत्र

26,644

भूटानी शरणार्थी जेष्ठ नागरिक स्वदेश फिर्ती समितिले आइतबार बेलायती राजदुत एण्ड्रय जेम्स स्पार्कलाई स्वदेश फिर्तीको पहल गर्न माग गर्दै आइतबार पत्र पठाएको छ ।

पत्र मार्फत २१ बर्ष देखि स्वदेश फर्कने आसामा बसेका शरणार्थीको नैसर्गिक अधिकारमाथि कुठराघात भएको बताउँदै विभिन्न अन्तराष्ट्रिय निकायमा घर फर्कन पाउँने अधिकार सुनिश्चित गर्न पहलको लागि माग गरेको समितिका प्रबक्ता सन्तविर घलेले बताए ।

१ सय २७ जनाको प्रतिनिधि हस्ताक्षर सहित पठाएको पत्रमा समितिका संयोजक हर्कजङ्ग सुव्वाले हस्ताक्षर गरेका छन् ।

समितिले पटक पटक विभिन्न राष्ट्र र जिम्मेवार निकायलाई पत्र तथा ज्ञापन पत्र पठाउँदै आएको छ ।

सौजन्यः डिकेश लामा, बेलडागी

Rizal says, he is in open prison in Kathmandu

26,644

Senior human rights activist Tek Nath Rizal has recently accused the present Government of Nepal (GoN) of making him hostage in Kathmandu.

Tek Nath Rizal
Tek Nath Rizal

In a letter addressed to the Nepalese Ministry of Home Affairs (MoHA) on August 30, 66-years-old activist said his movement has been confined to just within Kathmandu as he has been denied of refugee identity card, and travel document.

According to Rizal, who has been diagnosed of chronic diabetes and high blood pressure, he has even not been able to travel to India or abroad for his treatment without identity card and travel document.

Nepal had issued him travel document years back, but his every request to renew the document was denied by a number of governments.

The Rizal’s letter requested the MoHA to understand his ‘pathetic’ conditions, and continue all possible supports for his survival.

According to Rizal, GoN has stopped providing the logistic supports that he had been getting to maintain his daily living in Kathmandu.

Following resettlement of his children in Canada in 2009, activist Rizal and his wife, Kaushila, have been living in Lalitpur for last 12 years.

My success will be a victory for the diverse community in Clarkston : Dhakal

Eleven years ago when Birendra Dhakal, 55, landed in Georgia, he would not have thought about contesting for any political office in the city of Clarkston which he chose as his home for rest of the life. In quite a polyglot city of Clarkston, he is now preparing his ground for starting a political career in the metro government vying for the seat of a councilman. Campaigns are already set in motion and Birendra pulls up shocks for fund raising.

Birendra Dhakal
Birendra Dhakal

A father of three, Birendra makes his regular income from a job at Georgia Aquarium. But the idea of political empowerment clicked to him when he began volunteering for teaching citizenship classes to fellow Bhutanese at Hindu Buddhist Spiritual center established by the community. Birendra and his wife Benu have been teaching citizenship education to elderly Bhutanese for the last four years.

Before becoming a refugee in Nepal, Birendra Dhakal was a planning officer at the Ministry of Agriculture, Royal Government of Bhutan. BNS Editor-In-Chief, Buddha Mani Dhakal, talked to Birendra Dhakal about his ongoing election campaign. Excerpts:

How is your campaign going on?
Our campaign is going on full swing. We have a team of supporters who are helping me run this campaign. We have raised enough money for the campaign. Soon we will be knocking at the doors of our neighbors asking for votes. I had the occasion to give two stump speeches, one at Baptist church and the other one at a fund raising dinner.(view the speech on my facebook )

What motivated you to go for the council election?
I became a citizen in 2010 when a large number of my country men arrived in Clarkston, GA. As I am interested in community development, I along with my wife Benu started teaching citizenship classes to the seniors and after three years, over 90% of them are confident of passing the citizenship test. It is during these classes I learned that we can even run for a public office in an election. I began to feel that political empowerment is a must, specially for minorities like us, in order to participate in the decision making process. So when my friend Ted, who is running for the Mayor of Clarkston suggested that I run for the council, I got motivated and finally decided to take the race.

Who are your voters? Why should they vote for you?
Clarkston population comprises of 58.4 % African Americans, 13.5% White Americans, 21% Asians and other minorities. Although, 21% Asian population comprises of Vietnamese, Burmese and Bhutanese,  the later two are ineligible to vote as they are not yet citizens. We have only one eligible Bhutanese voter living in our constituency.

If I am elected, I want to contribute to improving the educational standards of Clarkston kids, Safe and clean environment and leveraging diversity as strength and not a weakness for Clarkston.

What will happen to Clarkston’s immigrant and refugee population if you win the seat?
Clarkston has people from over 40 different countries speaking 54 different languages. The city council comprises of a mayor and 6 councilman. Except the Mayor, all the Councillors are white. Clarkston is the most diverse city in America hence I feel a representation from the diverse group would be a good thing for the council.

If I win the election it will be a great victory for the diverse community living in the city.

पूर्वाञ्चल स्तरीय भलिबल प्रतियोगिता शुरु

26,644

झापाको भूटानी शरणार्थी शिविर बेलडाँगीमा शुक्रबार देखि पूर्वाञ्चल स्तरीय भलिबल प्रतियोगिता शुरु भएको छ ।

पहिलो दिनको खेलमा सहभागी खेलाडीहरू (तश्विरः डिकेश लामा)
पहिलो दिनको खेलमा सहभागी खेलाडीहरू (तश्विरः डिकेश लामा)

उद्घाटन खेलमा बन्दका कारण सुव्वा चोक विर्तामोड टीम र पिपिरे, दमक टीमको उपस्थिति नभएको खेल आयोजक समूहका सचिव टिकाराम राईले बताए ।

यसै गरी दोस्रो खेल पनि साराडाँगी धाईजन झापालाई नेट बल हानी आयोजक बी टिम दोस्रो खेलमा प्रवेश गर्ने मौका पाएको छ ।

पाथीभरा शसस्त्र प्रहरी गणका प्रमुख तथा शसस्त्र प्रहरी उपरिक्षक महेश कुमार श्रेष्ठको प्रमुख आथित्यमा भएको उद्घाटन कार्याक्रममा दर्शकलाई खेल मनोरञ्जन दिन शसस्त्र प्रहरी बल पकली र आयोजक ए टीमले खेल प्रदर्शन गरेका थिए । खेलमा आयोजकलाई शसस्त्र प्रहरी बल पकलीले विजय हासिल गरेको कार्याक्रम संचालक विर्ख गुरुङ्गले बताए ।

शनिबार भने ज्ञान ज्योति क्लव सुरुङ्गा र झुम्का खेलकुद कमिटि तथा आयोजक सी टीम र धरान भलिवल क्लवबीच प्रतिस्पर्दा हुने आयोजक समूहले जानकारी दिएको छ ।

खेलमा विजेता र उपविजेता टीमलाई क्रमशः ४१ हजार र ३१ हजार नगद, ट्रफी, मेडल र प्रमाण पत्र प्रदान गरिने आयोजक समूहले जानकारी दिएको छ ।

सौजन्यः डिकेश लामा, बेलडागी

Teej, Janmastami in Melbourne, Sydney

26,644

The Bhutanese women of Melbourne organised Teej Puja on September 8 amidst various programs.

Women engage themselves in Puja in Melbourne
Women engage themselves in Puja in Melbourne

Around 100 women and girls observed the festival where youths and senior members of the community also contributed for the ceremony informed the organizer.

Meanwhile, the community also observed the Shri Krishna Janma Asthami at Senior Citizenship Club, Glenroy on August 28.

Organised by the senior members of the community, the day was celebrated with Puja, Bhajan, and religious funfares.

While, the Bhutanese Association in Victoria (BAV) also organized Panchami Puja that is the final part of Teej in Hindu culture.

The Bhutanese priest, Mitra Adhikari, inaugurated the Victoria program enchanting mantras supported by guru Naryan Adhikari, who has recently moved to Melbourne from Tasmania.

Bhutanese women celebrating Teej in Sydney
Bhutanese women celebrating Teej in Sydney

BNS Correspondent from Sydney reports that the community celebrated this year’s Teej festival on Sunday.

The event that begun from 11 am lasted until 5 pm, the organizer informed.

“Importance of celebrating festivals like Teej has doubled where in Australia,” said Damanta Kafle (Sapkota), the Female Coordinator of Association of Bhutanese in Australia (ABA) Sydney.

ABA Sydney organized the program coordinated by Ambika Dhungel.

(With inputs from Devi Ghimire in Melbourne, and Padam Kafle in Sydney)