Bird enthusiasts can follow a feather-loving flight path to a special, free event 6:30-7:30 p.m. Wednesday, Sept. 26, at the public library. Two bird clubs will sponsor avian enthusiast and photographer from Bhutan, Chubzang Tangbi.
The St. Croix Valley Bird Club, which has many members and activities in River Falls, and the St. Croix Falls-based Gaylord Nelson Audobon Society partnered to bring the event to both their memberships and communities.
“This will be our first joint effort,” said local member of the SCVBC Cathy Olyphant. “Everyone is very excited about him coming. This will be our first international speaker.”
Chubzang Tangbi (Picture Courtesy : River Fall Journal)
She met Michelle Carlisle, the GNAS member with whom she’s been coordinating Tangbi’s visit, at a training program of the Friends of the St. Croix Wetland Management.
Carlisle received the ‘heads-up’ call from fellow birder and Tangbi’s “personal assistant,” Cathy Ley, during his visit to Wisconsin.
Ley met Tangbi when she worked at the International Crane Foundation in Baraboo, a job that piqued her interest in birds.
While in Bhutan, ICF’s founder had met Tangbi, who later visited the ICF twice for an internship.
A premier birder of Bhutan and professional photographer as well, Tangbi’s talk includes a kind of image-driven tour through Bhutan and its mix of alpine and jungle environments that tout “beautiful landscapes with amazing flora, fauna, and avian species.”
Bhutan is said to be one of the world’s top 10 biodiversity hotspots.
Said Ley: “He’s doing 21 speaking engagements,” most in Wisconsin, with some in Illinois.
River Falls will be Tangbi’s next-to-last presentation before returning home. Audiences have included “way more people than we thought.”
Ley says Tangbi has been overwhelmed by people’s response and interest but is pleased to be educating them about his country.
Ley said his presentation lasts about 40 minutes. People may ask questions or talk with Tangbi afterward.
Olyphant agrees that while birders will be interested in catching a glimpse of a species they’ve never seen before, the event will be interesting for anyone since he talks about his culture and traditions.
She adds, “Bhutan is known for its gross national happiness.”
The SCVBC member says the local club is moving into its ‘speaker season with one who accomplishes the club’s first mission of “to educate.” Generally, May through August are active watching months, and speakers come during the other months except December.
A Bhutan story According to his web site, Tangbi was born and raised in Trongsa, Central Bhutan — a small country nestled into the Himalayan mountains between India and China. He is an avid bird enthusiast, professional photographer, tour guide with Langur Eco Travels and goodwill ambassador for his native land.
He believes strongly in protecting his country’s environment, as well as its culture, traditions and heritage. Bhutan sits where “snow-capped mountains, verdant valleys, dense jungles and crystal-clear rivers combine with a calming ancient Buddhist culture.”
Tangbi grew up in a remote village, roaming the jungle to enjoy all kinds of new discoveries. The country has three, main environmental areas: sub-tropic lowlands, temperate zone and alpine zone.
Bhutan has 70% forested land and is committed to leaving at least 60% of that way in perpetuity. Nature-protection policies go hand-in-hand with the Buddhist way of life.
It also has 650 species of birds, 221 global endemic bird areas, more than 120 types of butterflies and 750 plant species. And a piece of Bhutan’s history makes the photographic tour even more intriguing: Outside visitors have only been allowed since a Bhutanese king decided to allow it in 1970.
Bhutan has established diplomatic relations with the Republic of Slovenia and United Arab Emirates (UAE), as both the countries signed a joint communique on September 13 in New York.
Lhatu Wangchuck (L) with Sanja Stiglic (Picture courtesy : MoFA)
Bhutan’s Permanent Representative to the UN Lhatu Wangchuck and his Slovenian counterpart Sanja Stiglic signed the communique, Ministry of Foreign Affairs stated.
“At the signing, the two ambassadors expressed the interest of their governments to cooperate closely in the bilateral and multilateral fields,” added the report.
In a separate ceremony, the Joint Communiqué on the establishment of diplomatic relations was signed between Lhatu Wangchuk, Ambassador and Permanent Representative of Bhutan to the United Nations in New York, and his UAE counterpart Ahmed Al-Jarman at the Permanent Mission of the United Arab Emirates in New York.
Slovenia is the 41st country with which Bhutan has established diplomatic relations. The UAE is the 42nd country to tie with Bhutan.
शिविरमा सम्पन्न प्रतियोगिताको एक झलक । तस्वीर डिकेश लामा
झापाको बेलडाँगी भूटानी शरणार्थी शिविरमा मंगलबारदेखि शुरु भएको सेक्टर स्तरीय भलिबल टुर्नामेन्टको शुक्रबार भएको खेलमा बेलडाँगी २ को सेक्टर बी र सी विजयी भएका छन् ।
युवा मैत्री केन्द्र बेलडाँगीको आयोजना तथा क्यारिटस नेपालको सहयोगमा भएको टुर्नामेन्टमा पुरुष तर्फको खेलमा बेलडाँगी २ सेक्टर सी लाई हराएर सेक्टर बी ले विजय हात पारेको हो । महिला तर्फको खेलमा भने बेलडाँगी २ सेक्टर एफलाई हराउँदै बेलडाँगी ३ सेक्टर इ सेमी फाइनलमा प्रवेश गरेको छ ।
पुरुष तर्फ १५ र महिला तर्फ १० टीम सहभागी रहेको खेल प्रतियोगितामा भोलि बेलडाँगी २ को पुरुष तर्फ सेक्टर ए र आम्दा समूह तथा महिला तर्फ बेलडाँगी २ को सेक्टर एच र सी बीच प्रतिष्पर्धा हुने केन्द्रका फिल्ड स्टाफ मनबहादुर पौडेलले बताए ।
दमकको बेलडाँगी भूटानी शरणार्थी शिविर क्षेत्रमा रहेको बेलडाँगी बजारमा लामो समयदेखि फोहोर नउठाएको कारण फोहोर व्यवस्थापनमा समस्या आएको छ ।
विभिन्न ५ स्थानमा राखेको फोहोर राख्ने भाँडो भरिए पछि बजारमा फोहोर व्यवस्थापनमा समस्या आउँन थालेको हो । फोहोर राख्न सिमेन्टबाट बनाइएको डम्पिङ्ग भाँडो भरिएर फोहोर फाल्न समस्या भएको बजारका व्यवसायी भिम भट्टराईले बताए ।
यता बेलडाँगी बजार व्यवस्थापन समितिले दमक नगरसँग फोहोर उठाउँन पटक पटक भन्दै आएको भए पनि नगर पालिकाले चासो नदेखाएको कारण समस्या आउँन थालेको समितिका अध्यक्ष नैंनसिंह भण्डारीले बताए ।
Former central chairperson of the Bhutanese Refugee Women Forum (BRWF), Leela Limbhu ‘Nisha’ is of the opinion that the Bhutanese community would be really proud if young writers emerge from every refugee hut.
She has said that writers in camps are not merely focussed to creations on love affairs, claiming that they have been revealing very good stories out of their suffering and pain provoked by unfruitful camp life. However, she expressed her sadness over lack of women writers in the community.
Prior to her resettlement in the United States weeks ago, Nisha talked to Vidhyapati Mishra of the Bhutan News Service about her literary career and other related aspects.
The Youth Friendly Center (YFC) organised one-day orientation workshop on mentor-mentee for youths of camps, Wednesday.
Participants of the workshop/Picture : BNS
According to the organizer, the trained youths (mentors would work as mentor and start assisting children (mentees) at risk.
Addressing the opening ceremony, Armed Police Force (APF) Inspector of Beldangi, Bijay Hamal requested the youths in camps to co-operate for maintaining peace and order in the community.
He also expressed hope that such a program would benefit the vulnerable children at risk.
Meanwhile, Mentor-Mentee Program Coordinator, Anup Maiji SJ, highlighted the importance of the program in the present context.
The program is managed under the regular funding of Caritas Nepal.
Dr David L Luechauer has caused quite a stir in Bhutan with his open criticism of GNH. He taught with the Gaeddu College of Business Studies as a lecturer for a year but had to cut short his two year stint due to his wife’s health concerns. He is teaching at the Krannert School of Management in the USA under Purdue University a global top 50 program. Apart from an extensive academic background Dr David advises major business companies in USA. He talks to The Bhutanese in an in-depth interview.
Picture courtesy : The Bhutanese
How can our leaders make GNH a better model?
I am not sure they can nor am I sure that it is their job to improve the model. Model building is for academics not leaders. I would argue that leaders should stop worrying so much about whether Bhutan pursues and measures GNH, GNP, or GDP and should focus instead on building the basic infrastructure of the country, putting in place the laws, processes and programs that will force the country and the people to become more self-sufficient and self-reliant and making sure that the foundations of democracy are in place and secure. In my most contrarian moments, I sometimes wish or think that Bhutan should return to being a monarchy and that the King should follow the model Jack Welch used to save General Electric. Bhutan needs to get into the game before telling others how to play the game and right now, Bhutan isn’t even in the stadium.
In your article you say that the Brazil GNH conference was a failure of sorts and that Bhutan and GNH’s 15 minutes fame is up. Can you please elaborate?
I was just quoting what I had read reported on a variety of websites which lamented the fact that what emerged from Brazil was a document much toned down from that which was discussed at the United Nations. As for 15 minutes of fame, the clock is ticking. Unless Bhutan could really show that is has something to offer the world beyond platitudes and pronouncements. Bhutan must show that it possesses substantive working models of excellence in education, commerce, health, personal well being, etc. that are directly attributable to the pursuit and practice of GNH. Bhutan simply does not have such levels of excellence to show the world. Hence, to the extent that people, outside a few economists, academics, and environmentalist, who had much interest in Bhutan will soon lose whatever interest they may have had in the country except for being a tourist destination. As I said, Bhutan would have been better to have flown under the radar and not touted GNH until it was ready or could document that it had better schools, hospitals, businesses, products, and overall social living conditions than more developed nations.
Your article also says, “Brazil’s GNH conference is only a failure if Bhutan doesn’t learn the simple lesson that both charity and development begin at home.” What did you mean?
I think international aid and international support will be contingent upon other world leaders and people of other nations first seeing that Bhutan is pulling itself up by its own bootstraps. Right now, the consensus among those who care is that the Bhutanese leaders and people must learn the difference between a handout and a hand up. We heard this a lot from those in the medical field who were visiting Bhutan and trying to effect change in Bhutanese medical practices. It’s hard to describe without sounding mean spirited but the attitude many expatriates experience when dealing with Bhutanese and Lisa Napoli documents this fairly well in her book, is “I’m so poor -give me, give me” or “get me out of here.” It’s like a cultural neurosis of looking and waiting for a savior instead of realizing that the answers lie within and at home. It’s time the Bhutanese people understand they must roll up their sleeves and get down to some very hard work at building an economy. It was common knowledge that the least hardworking faculty at GCBS was the Bhutanese faculty! It is strange but whenever we had visitors and we had some very prominent visitors to the college, the Bhutanese faculty were rarely if ever present.
GNH has heavy international intellectual backing with people like professor Jeffrey Sach, Joseph Stiglitz etc endorsing GNH. Surely they know something?
Obviously brilliant men with a very clear leftist liberal agenda. You want me to trot out the list of equally famous, equally brilliant right wing economists with their own agenda who would oppose GNH as measure? It is a philosophy, it has its supporters and detractors, show me a philosophy that does not have brilliant minds on both sides of the issue. I will say this, I’d like to see either one of them come and live and teach under the exact same conditions as the faculty at GCBS and see if they are still supporters of GNH.
What are the flaws that you see in the current GNH philosophy?
Honestly, I have no particular “quibble” with GNH as a philosophy. My concerns lie in the area of operationalization, Bhutan taking the “lead” in advocating GNH when so much basic work needs to be done home and for the people of Bhutan, and the deleterious effect the pursuit of this model particularly the “happiness” component is and will continue to have on the people of Bhutan.
From a philosophical standpoint, if I had to state two major concerns they would simply be. First, there is no consensus on the key variable “happiness.” what it means or how to measure it. Second, it seems to be propelling Bhutan toward socialism at a time when even countries like China are moving toward a more free market capitalistic orientation.
The main pitch of Bhutan’s message to the international community is to supplant GDP with GNH and in doing so avoid the dangers of unchecked modernization like climate change, conflict over resources, breakdown of social values etc. What is wrong with that?
The underlying assumption that GNH is needed to do this and your own phrasing of the question, assuming that modernization is currently unchecked. Why do you say unchecked? The last time I looked, many nations of the world were passing and enforcing laws on everything from human rights and environmental protection to consumer/product safety codes. Your question, as is so often the case in the GNH literature, shows no real understanding that a country could measure GDP or GNP and still practice as much or more GNH related principles than Bhutan currently demonstrates. However, at the end of the day, I think politicians of either persuasion put too much emphasis on either GNP or GNH. The real issue is not what we measure but how we behave.
I teach leaders and aspiring leaders around the world, they run everything from small entrepreneurial ventures to fortune 500 companies. Except for the few who have either a background or an inclination toward economics, they never talk about GNP, GDP, and GNH. They are much more concerned with accounting, financial and managerial principles than economic models. If you think GDP drives decision-making in company you are being naïve. GDP or GNP is an economic number reported every few months in the media. It is a point of information to which some may or may not pay attention. Conversely, the business students and leaders I know and work with check the global markets every day and many check those markets numerous times a day. So, you tell me which is more important to decision making in the USA – the GNP numbers or the DOW Jones Average, which is more important in Tokyo their GNP numbers or the Nikkei Index. Those other numbers drive policies and behaviors not the GNP numbers.
Some public health students will cite other people’s suffering as the motivation for pursuing their chosen career. A visit to sub-Saharan Africa may have been the tug. Or a stint volunteering at a homeless shelter. Or a heightened awareness of world hunger or disease.
Mishra speaks to fellow international health students about his experiences (Picture courtesy : Boston University School of Public Health)
For Tej Mishra, it was eight days of waiting for someone to look in his ear.
Mishra, now a master’s student at the BU School of Public Health, remembers the excruciating pain of an ear infection he suffered at age 11, while living in a refugee camp in Nepal with his family, who had fled their native Bhutan. One day went by — then five, then eight — while he waited to be seen by a medical clinician who tended to the 21,000 refugees huddled in bamboo-and-plastic huts in a Bhutanese camp in the Jhapa region of eastern Nepal.
“I just remember I cried, day and night, from the pain,” Mishra recalled. “I was a kid. There was nothing to do but wait.”
A decade later, when he speaks to fellow students at BUSPH — as he did earlier this year to Monica Onyango’s international health class in “Managing Disasters & Complex Humanitarian Emergencies” — Mishra cites those eight days as the beginning of a narrative of salvation.
“My passion to pursue public health was rooted in that experience,” he explained. “I learned from childhood that public health is the main social issue that needs to be addressed, before anything else can be tackled. There can be no education, no future, without adequate health care.”
Mishra, who is majoring in international health, with an interest in biostatistics and research design, is a study in resilience. At age 5, his family fled Bhutan, a remote and impoverished country in southern Asia, after his father, of Nepalese heritage, was forced out of the country in what Mishra describes as widespread ethnic cleansing.
Mishra would spend the next 18 years in a refugee camp with his parents and siblings before finding his way to a private college in Nepal — and then, in 2010, to the United States.
His memories of the early days in the refugee camp are dark: His brothers and parents holding up the plastic roof in driving rains, infectious diseases spreading from one family to the next, the dead being burned and thrown into the river. Even after U.N. assistance arrived, living conditions were grim, with rationed food and little opportunity for employment or integration into Nepalese society. Mishra was schooled at the camp until high school, when he received aid from a charitable group to attend a private school in Nepal.
“One of the saddest issues of being a refugee is the hatred you face from the local community,” he said. “I was a Nepali, by race, but you are not supposed to go outside and work or make something of yourself, even if you have talent…
“A complete generation of my community has been lost,” he said. “Most of them were not allowed to do anything, for 20 years.”
After high school, Mishra enrolled in Pokhara University in Nepal, working his way through school by tutoring other students and with support from his older brothers. He had known, from an early age, that he wanted to pursue a career in public health, and after the family immigrated to Virginia, he applied to and was accepted into BUSPH.
The boy who wore “a single shirt” through the fourth, fifth and sixth grades now bounds across campus in jeans and sneakers, with a backpack full of experts’ views on international health dilemmas. He does not resent the experiences of his youth — in fact, in some ways, he cherishes them.
“My school days are what I remember the most — sitting on a dusty floor, on a sack I brought from home, listening to teachers from Bhutan who had been schooled in the Indian education system. It’s funny — in some ways, I miss those moments,” he said. “Not the conditions — I would never have had the opportunities to do what I can do here. It’s mainly the human or emotional aspect that I miss.
“There were some aspects of life there that will never be here. It was a community for me, in a way that’s difficult to explain.”
That community continues today in Nepal, where an estimated 60,000 refugees from Bhutan remain in camps, while tens of thousands of others have resettled in the U.S., Australia, Canada and other countries. The Bhutanese refugees first entered Nepal at the end of 1990, where temporary camps were established on the banks on the Mai River. Disease and squalor were rife.
A few years later– within months after Mishra and his family arrived — the United Nations Refugee Agency and the World Food Program began providing assistance to the Bhutanese refugees, including food, water, shelter, health and education.
While violence is minimal within the refugee population, the structural layout of the camps is very dense, with shelters built close together, the UN reports. Frequent fires cause widespread damage, and flooding from rain is common.
Mishra stays in touch with friends at the camps, as well as one of his sisters, who has stayed behind by choice, he said. He has no interest in returning to Bhutan, a country he said is largely misunderstood by the west, in terms of its policies on human rights and social justice. Bhutan’s government forced ethnic Nepalis to leave the country through a variety of tactics, including imprisonment, according to Human Rights Watch and other international watchdog groups. The Bhutanese refugee situation is now one of the most protracted refugee crises in the world.
“Bhutan is not the way the world sees it,” Mishra said. “Not all ethnic groups are allowed to go to school or obtain jobs. Yes, foreigners are warmly welcomed, but they see only the cultural attractions the government wants them to see. And the people in the local villages –they are afraid for their lives to speak the truth against the government.”
He said he is discouraged that so little attention has been paid to the plight of Nepalese refugees:
“There is a chance that the sufferings of my parents will remain as a forgotten history.”
Mishra said he doesn’t broadcast his own history, but he welcomes opportunities to educate others about the refugee experience. In late October, he will be speaking to a class of first-year medical students about refugee life from a public health perspective.
Joe Anzalone, senior manager of the BUSPH Department of International Health, said he’s been impressed by Mishra’s energy and focus.
“Tej is incredibly determined and genuine. Because of his unusual path to BUSPH, I had concerns about his readiness to excel in his coursework. However, I’ve seen the great capacity Tej has for hard work. He has incredible drive and discipline,” Anzalone said.
Rich Feeley, associate chair and professor of international health, said Mishra “spends long hours around the Department. He does very well [academically] for someone who never had the advantages of a U.S. education until he came here. He is clearly a person who takes his public health education seriously.”
While Mishra still has time to decide what to do with the master’s degree he will receive in 2013, he says he would like to find a way to work with the refugees. But he would not be content to help them merely to endure.
“We think in one perspective: that if we provide food and water and basic necessities, that is what people need to survive,” he said. “But if we look deeper, survival is not enough.
“People need opportunities to live healthy, productive lives. I have the opportunity now. I want to use it to help other people.”
Some 1090 Japanese nationals including officials from Ministry of Foreign Affairs extended their generous donations amounting Nu 7.4 million for reconstruction of Wangduephodrang Dzong gutted by massive fire recently.
Honorary Consul-General of Bhutan in Tokyo, Hitomi Takuda, handed over the donations to Foreign Secretary, Yeshey Dorji, Monday in Thimphu, reports Kuensel.
Takuda said that the donation was a “thank you so much” from Japanese people for the royal visit paid by the King last year.
झापाको बेलडाँगीस्थित भूटानी शरणार्थी शिविरमा मंगलबारदेखि सेक्टर स्तरीय भलिबल प्रतियोगिता शुरु भएको छ ।
शिविरमा सम्पन्न प्रतियोगिताको एक झलक । तस्वीर डिकेश लामा
युवा मैत्री केन्द्र बेलडाँगीको आयोजना तथा क्यारिटस नेपालको सहयोगमा भएको उक्त प्रतियोगिता औपचारिक कार्यक्रमबीच शुरु गरिएको छ । मंगलबार भएको पुरुष तर्फको खेलमा बेलडाँगी २ विस्तारित सेक्टर सीलाई वाक ओभर दिँदै बेलडाँगी २ सेक्टर डी टोली विजयी घोषित भएको छ । महिला तर्फको खेलमा बेलडाँगी २ को सेक्टर इ लाई लगातार २ सेटमा हराई सेक्टर एचले विजय हात पारेको छ ।
औपचारिक कार्यक्रम युएनएचसीआरकी फिल्ड सहायक गंगा सेनको प्रमुख आतिथ्य तथा केन्द्रकी संयोजक डम्बरकुमारी राईको सभापतित्वमा भएको थियो । कार्यक्रममा स्थानीय संघसंस्था, सशस्त्र प्रहरी सुरक्षा बेश, क्याम्प रेखदेख समिति, क्याम्प व्यवस्थापन समिति लगायतका पदाधिकारीको उपस्थिति रहेको थियो ।
पुरुष तर्फ १५ र महिला तर्फ १० टीम सहभागी रहेको खेलमा प्रतियोगितामा भोलि बेलडाँगी २ को पुरुष तर्फ सेक्टर एच र इ तथा महिला तर्फ सेक्टर वी र ए बीच प्रतिष्पर्धा हुने केन्द्रका अगुवा पदाधिकारी मनबहादुर पौडेलले बताएका छन् ।