Bhutan as vice-chair of 16th NAM summit

26,644

Bhutan has been elected as one of the vice chairs of the 16th summit of the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM), which began in the capital city of Iran, Tehran, Thursday.

PM Thinley addresses the 16th NAM Summit (Picture courtesy : Cabinet Secretariat)

Prime Minister Jigmi Y Thinley delivered a statement at the summit’s opening session as the Vice Chair of the summit on behalf of the Asia-Pacific states of the NAM after the Summit opened with Iran assuming the Chair from Egypt for the next three years, a statement issued by the Cabinet Secretariat mentioned.

PM Thinley conveyed the gratitude of the Asian group members of the NAM to the people and government of the Islamic Republic of Iran.

He said that “just as we are touched by the generosity and warmth of the Iranian hospitality, we are also inspired by the history and culture of this great nation. And we are certain that the city of Tehran will deliver to our summit a very successful outcome.

The summit’s inaugural session was also marked by opening remarks of President of the Islamic Republic of Iran Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, Egyptian President Muhammed Morsi and UN Secretary General Ban Ki Moon.

The PM said that as Egypt passes on to Iran the mantle of the Movement’s leadership, the Asia Pacific region wishes to place on record deep appreciation for the outstanding manner in which the outgoing Chair steered NAM through a tumultuous period.

One certainty in out turbulent world, he said, is the rapidity and growing complexity of change and so the future years will be increasingly challenging. “But the dedication and commitment with which Iran assumed the role of stewardship, give us the confidence that NAM will continue to be a powerful and positive force in shaping the destiny of human society,” he said adding that to this end, the Asian group welcomes the offer of Venezuela to host the next summit.

He also said that the high quality of the reports and the outcome documents which are about to be adopted, bear not only evidence of the knowledge but hard work of the teams of both the outgoing and current chairs. PM Thinley further said that they also speak eloquently of the spirit of understanding and accommodation with which the member states are prepared to cooperate towards a more peaceful, harmonious and happier world. He assured the gathering that the Asian pacific group will continue to contribute actively and meaningfully to the principles, vision and endeavour of the Movement.

Meanwhile, he also met with the President of Benin Dr. Thomas Yayi Boni, who currently holds the presidency of the African Union, His Royal Highness the Prince of Jordan Hassan bin Talal, special envoy of the Prime Minister of Australia Julia Gillard and the leader of the delegation of Vietnam. He also met and interacted with several other heads of states and governments, and leaders of delegations.

EC withdraws its ad decision

26,644

The Election Commission(EC) has finally revoked its earlier decision to distribute election advertisements only to state-owned media.

A circular issued by the EC on Tuessday said that its advertisements would go to all media, as was the practice in the past.

According to Chief Election Commissioner Kunzang Wangdi, the decision was made, following a review of the “clarification” government made through a press release last week.

Based on instruction of the Ministry of Finance, the EC earlier published a circular that all advertisements related to the upcoming election would only be given to Kuensel, Bhutan Broadcasting Service (BBS) and Kuzoo FM.

The decision received widespread criticism from various sectors including the social media.

‘Education is declining drastically’

26,644

Like others, the former Camp Secretary of Timai camp, Yubaraj Sampang, feels that education standard in camp is decreasing drastically these days. He regards that the ongoing third country resettlement is responsible for inviting such a fate to us. BNS Regional News Coordinator, Tilak Niroula, has talked to Sampang in this regard and other relevant issues. Excerpts: 

Yubaraj Sampang (Picture : Durga Pokhrel/BNS)

How do you comment on education standard in the camp schools?
I am sad to mention here that the education standard in camps is dramatically decreasing. Actually, this should not have happened. I regard that the ongoing third country resettlement is responsible for inviting such a fate to us. The resettlement has transformed everything in camp, and the education sector has suffered a lot.

What are its remedies?
A single person cannot do anything to improve the situation. We must motivate our children, encourage our teachers, and extend possible supports for reenergizing everyone involved in this sector. We can expect some better results, but not immediately. We need to be serious towards this since it involves thousands of future heroes.

How do you see Beldangi camp?
I have ample of parallels to compare Beldangi with my former camp Timai. The situation is quite compelling to live in. Problems among youths are at a rapid growth. In most cases, people from Timai, Goldhap or Khudunabari are blamed of bringing such kinds of problems. But, this is not the reality. We are one community, and such segregation should not prevail anymore.  To some extent, the situation is not appreciable and praiseworthy. The camp management committee should take the responsibility.

Regarding security situation?
Timai was a small camp. Beldangi camps have higher population, and of the three camps Beldangi-II is the most crowded place to dwell in. More people means more problems and disorders. The security system should be liberal enough to allow refugees exercise their rights in a full manner. But, this doesn’t mean that they should be allowed to do whatever they wish. We must have a hazard-free camp environment without any frauds and intended exploitations.

Is repatriation possible?
The resettlement countries in the west have already accepted over 68,000 of fellow countrymen. Still, more are in the queue, and would leave us in near future. We have waited for almost two decades. I am sure that Bhutan will have no excuse in accepting some of the refugees back home with dignity and honour sooner or later. Nepal will not allow refugees to assimilate locally. Above all, the resettlement programme has sidelined the issue of repatriation in a complete sense. But, this will not be for a long time. Thus, we need patience for that.

Being the President of Fans Club, what are your plans ahead?
Indeed, I am proud to say that the Fans Club is getting popular among the refugees in camps, and outside. This is possible since we have organised various soccer tournaments in the past. We do have plans for future programmes, but we lack resources. We are financially handicapped to bring our all plans into actions. But, we’ll soon organise inter-club regional football tournament in the eastern region.

Private media and DPT government

26,644

For the last one month, Bhutanese private media companies have been grumbling over the DPT government’s bias against private media over the issue of government advertisements given only to state owned media like BBS, Kuzoo FM and Kuensel.  The tussle is ongoing.

Private media companies in Bhutan are staggering under the low return of their actual investment and lower percentage of regular news consumers in the country. Advertisements provide lifeblood for their sustenance/survival. But the lingering question is: Why the minister of information, Nanda Lal Rai, issued directives not to provide any advertisements or government notifications to the media houses? Did he mean it to quell the private media companies ultimately?

The public has the right to information as enshrined in the constitution. And, the RTI bill is yet to get stamped by both houses to make it a law. When the private media, particularly ‘The Bhutanese’, has set out to report in more investigative vigor, the DPT government and Prime Minister Jigmi Y Thinley seems to be tailgating the media houses. The report on Gyalpozhing land case, Trowa Theater, Denchi and even the case of sacking a Principal of Dorokha school are what The Bhutanese found to contain some foul play by the government.

Other private media companies like Bhutan Today, Business Bhutan and even Bhutan Times are indicating the ‘dry’ source of financing their business. The reporters in all these companies have complained about the irregular and reduced salary they get from their employers. So, it has become almost gripping for the private media in Bhutan to shut down and let their employees run for other professions. Do we want these media to shut down in a Democratic Bhutan?

Chief Editor of Bhutan News Service, the author can be reached at: [email protected]

Dago Tshering in Havana

26,644

As a special envoy of Prime Minister, Dago Tshering, Bhutan’s ambassador to India, visited Cuba August 7-10 to discuss the bilateral prospects in the field of education and medicine.

Dago Tshering discusses Bhutan’s efforts to expand yet another tie with a communist country after China (Picture courtesy : Cuban Ministry of Foreign Affairs)

During his visit Tshering met with the acting foreign minister of Cuba, Marcelino Medina and called on Vice-president Estaben Lazo.

During the meeting of two sides, areas of bilateral cooperation like fielding of Cuban doctors in Bhutan and Bhutanese students studying in Cuba were discussed, besides Bhutan’s lobby to seek the non-permanent seat in UN Security Council.

Dago Tshering also affirmed his recognition for Cuba’s contribution towards educational development in Bhutan, according to Havana Radio.

The acting foreign minister of Cuba, Marcelino Medina thanked  Tshering for Bhutan’s support  to fifty-years-long struggle of Cuban people  against US hostility, reports Radio Havana Cuba.

Meanwhile, two students from Bhutan, four from Sri Lanka and three from India are ready to fly to Cuba for their higher study in medicine. The students from Bhutan and India met Cuban Ambassador to India, Abelardo Cueto on August 25, who gave useful advice to those aspiring students on their stay in Cuba.

Bhutan, with constitutional monarchy as the head of state, has opened the floodgates of diplomatic relations even with the communist country like Cuba and now considering the diplomatic ties with China, the northern communist giant.

लागुऔषध सहित पक्राउ

डिकेश लामा

झापास्थित भूटानी शरणार्थी शिविर वेलडाँगीमा एक युवालाई लागु औषधसहित पक्राउ गरिएको छ ।

वेलडाँगी शिविर । फाइल फोटो बि. एन्. एस्.

पक्राउ पर्नेमा बेलडाँगी २ सेक्टर इ-१, छाप्रा नं. ७ का २२ वर्षीय विनोद राई रहेका छन् । राईलाई शनिवार २४ थान विभिन्न नामका इन्जेक्सनबाट प्रयोग गरिने एम्पुल औषधिसहित पक्राउ गरिएको शसस्त्र प्रहरी सुरक्षा बेस क्याम्प बेलडाँगीका निरीक्षक विजय हमालले बताए ।

प्रक्राउ परेका राईलाई शिविर रेखदेख समितिको सहयोगमा पक्राउ गरिएको जनाइएको छ ।

यस अघि भूटानी शरणार्थी शिविरका ३ शरणार्थीलाई ७८ थान डाईजिपम, बु्रफेन, पेनागन लगायतका एम्पुलसहित पक्राउ गरी इलाका प्रहरी कार्यालय दमकमा बुझाइएको शसस्त्र बेस क्याम्प बेलडाँगीले जानकारी दिएको छ ।

पछिल्लो समय भूटानी शरणार्थी शिविर बेलडाँगीमा लागु औषध प्रयोगकर्ताहरु बढ्दै गएको शसस्त्र प्रहरी सुरक्षा बेसक्याम्प बेलडाँगीले जानकारी दिएको छ । लागुऔषध पदार्थहरु भारतको पानी टयाङ््कीबाट ल्याइने गरेको पक्राउ पर्नेहरुको बयान रहेको प्रहरीले जानकारी दिएको छ ।

BRCF conducts dance competition

26,644

The Bhutanese Refugee Children Forum (BRCF) organized an Inter-School Dance Competition in Beldangi, Saturday.

A child participant dances in a Nepali song (Picture : Durga Pokhrel/BNS)

Students from all the camp schools participated in the competition where Anita Biswa from Mari Gold Academy (MGA), Alina Rai from Pancha-Oti English School (PES) and Pabitra Rasaily from Tri-Ratna Secondary School (TRSS) secured first, second and third respectively.

Meanwhile stakeholders from various camp-based organizations attended and addressed the program.

The chairperson of the program, Bhim Monger, Co-ordinator of BRCF Beldangi requested the refugee-aid agencies to concentrate on child issues and to end violence against children.

A lost life

26,644

“Look not mournfully to the past. It comes not back again. Wisely improve the present. It is thine, go forth,” Henry Wadsworth Longfellow.

The bitter part of the past cannot be changed. I don’t want to re-think it, but the memories often resurface suddenly. I cannot avoid them.

Today, for some reason, I am reminded of an incident, which occurred in Bhutan. It was November 18, 1989, a winter’s day with a sunny clear sky. It was Saturday and I would work only half a day, to 1pm.

I was alone and busy with official work. At about 11am somebody knocked at the door. I looked up to see two people in the doorway.

“Are you Mr Sharma?” One enquired in a whispering voice.

“Yes I am,” I replied. He entered the Office and tiptoe close. In a single breath, he said; “We are directed by the Chief of Police to take you without delay to the Police Headquarters the Chief wants to talk to you confidentially.

They declined my invitation to sit down. They were acting strangely towards me, they seemed suspicious. I felt that something bad was about to happen. One man stood just inside the room and the other just out side the door. Every now and then they looked anxiously out the window, then to the door, as if they did not want anyone to see them.

Looking back, I believed the situation was planned so that I was left alone in the office. Three of my co-workers, all northern Bhutanese, were out of their offices. The other 11 workers were busy in the next building.

The stranger introduced themselves and showed me their identity cards. “Major and Inspector so & so.” They were Police officers in plain clothes.

“Your work can be done after visiting the Chief. You may face a difficult situation if anybody finds out that we are here.” They insisted that I leave with them immediately, my work unfinished.

Silently I rose, put the office keys on the table and followed them. No body knew that I was taken to the Police Headquarters.

At Headquarters they directed me to a room that was full of various implements used for torture. Terrified, I turned to leave, but in vain. Several people lined up to stop me. I was to sit and wait for the Police Chief to visit me.

The room was dusty and covered with cobwebs. There was no window and no electric light. Light passed only through the entrance door. In the room was a rough surfaced wooden table, a bench and a chair. I sat down on the bench and looked around me, then glanced back at the door. The guards were standing to attention, staring at me without blinking. Their stares filled me with fear.

The room was covered with chastisement tools. Leather whips of different lengths hung on the wall. Different bundles of shackles, handcuffs and thigh pressing vices were spread around the room. Many thorned wooden rods and bamboo punishment sticks of different sizes were lying on the floor. Other implements leant against the walls. Guns and rifles adorned the walls.

I shivered with intense fear. My mind raced, “They may beat me mercilessly with these harrowing tools.” My heart was beating fast, my body felt like jelly. My throat dried up. My head was spinning as if I was dizzy. I was bewildered. I couldn’t move or think clearly.

I waited for a long time for someone to come. I asked the people standing outside the door for a drink of water. One of them nodded as if he would bring one, but he didn’t. Hours passed. Finally an officer entered the room. I stood up out of respect for him. He looked seriously at me from head to toe

 “Hmmm… Sit down,” he said. He looked around the room for sometime then said, “Do you know why you have been brought here?”

 “No.” I replied honestly.

In a scornful voice he asked, “Do you know what these tools are used for?”

My body quivered. Hairs rose all over my body and I began to sweat. I didn’t understand what he wanted from me. I couldn’t answer him. He kept looking at me, furious. My heart was pounding.

After many minutes of silence he asked politely, “Did you meet Mr.Rizal after he fled the country?”

“Yes, I met him.”

“Why?” His eyes widened, eagerly anticipating my response.

“He is my relative and a friend.” Mr. Rizal was a Royal Councilor and people’s Representative from the South. He had seen through the Government’s slogan of ‘One Nation, One People’ and had petitioned the king to protect the religious, cultural and linguistic traditions of the various ethnic groups in Bhutan. As a result, he was harassed by police, regularly detained and eventually was forced to flee the country. From his self exile in Nepal Mr. Rizal continued to encourage the people to present a similar petition to the Government. Bhutanese agents abducted Mr. Rizal from Nepal. He was tortured and spent the next 11 years in Prison.

“Be careful. Don’t try to hide the fact.” He said, nodding his head slowly. He continued, “Do you know, he is against the Government? What message did he bring for you and your friends?”

I didn’t have an answer to his first question, but I answered his second.  He ordered me to write it down. His attendant brought a pen and paper for me and I was left alone.

After about an hour he returned. I gave him my statement and asked to go home. He said that it was not necessary for me to go home as he had enough room for me to stay there. I told him I would like to send a message to my family. He replied in such a way that I nearly fainted. He said,’ you made a notorious mistake meeting Mr. Rizal, and the result is that your family will not be informed of your whereabouts and you shall never get a chance of reunion with your family.”

He left and I was immediately taken to a room in another building with a bed on the floor. Four police guards were in the room with me, their eyes on me constantly. I was prohibited to speak.

That night, as I lay under the guards’ careful watch, I heard heavy boots coming up the stairs. The door opened with a loud bang. The Chief of Police entered and the guards quickly left the room. I was frightened. The Chief ordered me to write a fresh statement, this time adding points he told me to add. I expressed my discomfort at this but the Chief only stared fiercely and warned that, if I wanted to save my life, I should write what he told me to write.

I wanted to add my name to the petition to the Government, but under such coercion my statement expressed the opposite. I was told to write that Mr. Rizal wanted to dethrone the king, take over the country and create a greater Nepal. Further, I had to write that Mr. Rizal had ordered me to organize this in his absence and, if I refuse, Mr. Rizal would kill me. I gave the Chief my ‘statement’ and he left.

For the next two days I had to remain in the room lying down or sitting. I was not allowed to stand, walk around or look out the window. Each night I was locked in the room, with the light on, with four guards. A small can was provided for toileting for the five of us.

Late on the third day, again I heard heavy boots running up the stairs. With a bang the door opened and again the guards ran out. A police officer entered a revolver in his hand. I trembled with fear. He pointed the gun at my head for a while and said, ‘you wretched fellow,’ and stormed out muttering profanities.

Five days later he returned in the same fashion. Holding his gun by his side he spat out, ’Bastard’ and stormed out.

To this day, the memory of these events haunts me.

I learned later that my family wasn’t told my whereabouts until the tenth day of my detention. On that day the police brought me clothes from my house. I was desperately worried about my wife – what had happened to her? How was she coping with my absence?

I was in constant fear, not knowing what would happen to me next. I was never told what my alleged crime was. I couldn’t help thinking of the underground prison I had heard existed in the country where the Government put political prisoners. Their cases never go before a court and the prisoners never leave the gaol. They die inside the prison and their relatives are not told of their deaths. My imagination pictured the worst.

I had many visits from different police officers. Some were very polite and talked with me patiently. Others had cruel faces and uttered dirty words or phrases. It was very hard to hear, and to bear. Each time the door opened with a loud bang, a buzzing noise started in my ears.

Many days passed in this way. The nails in my hands and feet grew long. Once I signaled for a nail cutter. The guard shook his head. I didn’t like being unshaven and my uncombed hair started to matt together. My head itched day and night.

On the 50th day of my detention I was taken from my room to a barber, who cut my hair, beard and nails. I felt neat and tidy – and!  I saw four friends. I learned that forty people were arrested with me.

Several days later, one of them was brought to share my room. We weren’t allowed to speak, so we talked eye to eye and by hand signal when guard’s eyes were diverted. The chance of communicating in this way brought me some happiness, but didn’t last long. My friend was released after 15 days. Again I was alone, in lonely silence with my guards. In the depressing silence of the room with nothing to read, nothing to write with and no means of communicating with any one, I felt extremely alone and daily more depressed.

Three months after my arrest, I and six others taken to the Police Chief. He said that Druk Gyalpo, His Majesty the King, had generously granted us amnesty and we would be released. We signed a bond, the conditions of which were that we weren’t to speak with more than three people at once, we weren’t to go to a gathering place, move from one town to another or  leave our village.

I was driven by vehicle to my house. I found it had been locked by the owner. A neighbor told me that my wife and children left for our hometown in the south. It was cold and becoming dark. I asked a friend if I could stay with him. He refused, saying that the government would punish him if he allowed me in. Desperate I walked to a relative’s who responded the same way.

Having sat down for three months, walking was painful. Also, my treatment in those months caused me to lose some of my hearing. Dazed and with difficulty, I walked to another friend’s house who welcomed me. I thanked to him.

The next day I went to my Office and was told to report to Head Office.  There I was informed that by order of the Minister my employment was terminated. I was extremely upset at this news and I left the Office feeling desperate. I went to the bank and found my account had been forfeited. I went to the insurance company, to find my benefit also forfeited. I was also denied my shares in the Cement Industry. How to say? I had lost all I had ever earned.

I also lost many family and friends. Rumor had spread that if anyone was found talking to people who had been detained, they would be arrested and imprisoned. Only a few close friends dared to say hello. My movements were monitored and I was to report to the police every week.

A few months after returning home, with my wife and children a census was conducted in the village.  My wife’s National Identity Card, which proved her Bhutanese Citizenship, was confiscated. She and my children became non-citizens in their own birthplace. I became very nervous.

Soon I learned that those, like myself, who were given amnesty by the king, were being arrested and tortured. I was faced with a horrifying decision – to stay or to leave my country. I knew that whatever I chose, I had a dark future. Finally, the deteriorating situation in the country forced my hand.

When my wife, children and I left our motherland, everything we owned fit in a small plastic bag.

Oh! My birth land, I don’t have any mischief on you. I bow my head to the land of my heart.

I left the beloved land with tears in my eyes and sorrows in my heart. I left my country and journeyed towards an unknown destination and an uncertain future.

I lost my self-respect and dignity. I lost all of my belongings. I lost the country of my birth. I lost my enjoyment and happiness.

(The writer, who was born in 1954 in Samtse district and a former employee at Royal Insurance Corporation and Food Corporation of Bhutan, his wife Indira and their children spent 17 years in a refugee camp in Nepal before coming to Tasmania in 2008 as refugee. They are now rebuilding their lives and enjoying being part of an inclusive community). 

Editor’s note: This story was published in a magazine of Tasmania, Australia in, The Tasmanian Style issue 4 July 2012.                    

PDP finally clears state loans

26,644

The party in opposition said it cleared all pending debts this week, and accordingly notified the Election Commission that has been reviewing the party’s status to determine its eligibility for the general elections.

According to People’s Democratic Party (PDP) President Tshering Tobgay, his party cleared the government loan of more than Nu 20 million.

“The funds have come from all allowable sources,”Tobgay told the Kuensel.

Tobgay also clarified that the party was able to raise that sum from its members. The party has around 250 registered members throughout the country.

His basis was that such a huge amount of money came from general and annual membership fees, and generous contributions from some members.

“Political parties shouldn’t be permitted to take loans, especially since campaigning is financed by ECB,” Tshering Tobgay said. “Political parties must operate within their means. They should spend what they earn.”

Bhutan expands diplomatic tie with Swaziland

26,644

Bhutan has established diplomatic relations with Swaziland as the two countries singed a joint communique on New York, Tuesday.

Ambassadors of the two countries sign in the joint communique (Picture courtesy : Ministry of Foreign Affairs)

Permanent Representatives to the United Nations signed the communique expressing readiness of the two governments to cooperate bilaterally and mutually, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs said.

The Swaziland ambassador expressed the commitment of his government to support Bhutan’s candidacy for non-permanent membership for the UN Security Council, added the Ministry’s statement.

Swaziland, officially the Kingdom of Swaziland, and sometimes called Ngwane or Swatini, is a landlocked country in Southern Africa, bordered to the north, south and west by South Africa, and to the east by Mozambique.