Indian Prime Minister, Narendra Modi, arrived in Bhutan on Sunday in his two-day state visit. Special military aircraft carrying the Indian PM landed at Paro Airport at around 11:30 a.m. Bhutan Standard Time.
Indian PM receives guard of honor upon his arrival in Bhutan (Picture courtesy: Kuensel)
Prime Minister, Tshering Tobgay, received the Indian delegation comprising Minister for Foreign Affairs, Sushma Swaraj, National Security Advisor, Ajit Doval, and foreign secretary, Sujatha Singh. At least eight media persons have accompanied the delegation.
PM Modi’s cavalcade en route to the capital was cheered and welcomed by thousands of students, citizens and civil servants lined-up at various places.
Prime Ministers of both the countries discussed a wide range of issues including border dispute, hydropower and bilateral relationship among others, in their meeting, according to reports.
PM Tobgay said in his Tweet: “Very good discussions with PM @narendramodi He declared B4B: that Bharat is there for Bhutan, ready to support in all our endeavors.”
Upon his arrival at Paro Airport, Modi received guard of honor followed by another at the Royal palace in Thimphu. Several Indian media have been covering this visit live from Bhutan.
Modi also called King Jigme Khesar and the Queen later in the afternoon. At around 6:30 p.m., he inaugurated newly constructed building of the Supreme Court of Bhutan.
Prime Minister Modi is scheduled address a joint session of National Assembly and National Council, and lay foundation stone of one 600 MW hydroelectric project before flying back to New Delhi.
Tulsa Sharma, the first Nepali-speaking Bhutanese to earn a college degree from Dagana district in the Southern Bhutan, has published a book titled “Uprooted: The Unheard Story of the Bhutanese People of Nepali Origin”.
Published by the Dorrance Publishing Co. Inc based in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, the first time writer narrates her own story, from her childhood to the newly adopted American life, in an attempt to chronicle the state-sponsored ethnic cleansing of Bhutan.
The Tulsa’s book cover
The publisher claims, “The book follows Goshi from her childhood in a small village in Bhutan to her adolescence and schooling, and finally into her adulthood, all the while giving insight and understanding into the events leading up to the exile of the Bhutanese people.”
“She tells of their endurance and resilience, challenges and hardships; of how over a 100,000 of these people were marginalized from being part of a multicultural society and forced to fee the only home they knew to live as refugees in camps in eastern Nepal for seventeen years straight late 1980s.”
Commenting on her book, Dr Lakshmi Dhakal said, the book describes a village through a lens of simplicity.
According to him, not only as a victim but also as a narrator, a participant and yet a resilient person, such a write-up needs to be read by youths and educators not only to understand the true story of the people uprooted from their homes, their pain and sufferings, but also to feel emotions and flashbacks.
The writer, who has established herself as Goshi in the book, arrived in Virginia through the federally funded third country resettlement program in 2008. She is married to Bhutanese scholar and writer, Dr Narendra Sharma. The couple have two children.
The book is of 90 pages, and is available for purchase from the publisher and amazon. It’s priced US $11.
This letter, signed by the following signatories, was sent to Indian Prime Minister, Narendra Modi, on June 14, as he prepares to visit Bhutan from June 15. BNS has published this letter retaining its original content. An unofficial Hindi translation of this letter by BNS is available here.
Dear Mr. Prime Minister,
Please accept the heartiest felicitations and congratulations on your assumption of the prestigious Office of the Prime Minister of the Republic of India. The landslide victory that you have achieved truly reflects your dynamic leadership and commitment of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) towards the Indian nationals.
Indian Prime Minister, Narendra Modi (Picture courtesy: Mr. Modi’s publicly shared profile)
Mr. PM, we are also honored to know that Bhutan is the first country of your state visit. As we become confident that such a visit will take the Indo-Bhutan friendship to a new height, we also take this opportunity to draw your attention towards the plight of the Bhutanese refugees.
Mr. PM, you are visiting a country that has expelled over 100,000 of innocent citizens simply for raising their voices for democracy, human rights and equality in the kingdom. Unfortunately, these citizens have been rendered stateless for over 22 years as Bhutan is never in favor of accepting them back home. Nepal, which still continues to host thousands of these refugees letting others to resettle in the western countries, has failed to negotiate with Bhutan in finding an amicable solution of the crisis. Refugees, their leaders and the international community strongly believe that the right to return home of these refugees is completely vested on the Indian mercy. It is a matter of extreme sadness that none of the former governments of India paid attention towards this standoff.
Mr. PM, in your own words, your government is fully dedicated to poor, youth and women. The exiled Bhutanese populace not only comprises of poor, youth and women, but also hundreds of victims of torture, rape and other forms of state-sponsored suppression. We implore you to question the King, Jigme Khesar, and your Bhutanese counterpart, Tshering Tobgay, about fate of these citizens, pathetic situations of their relatives inside the country and political prisoners.
Mr. PM, reminding you of all aforementioned issues, we wholeheartedly appeal you to kindly make it your priority to generously engage India’s influential leadership in allowing all Bhutanese to fully exercise democracy and human rights, as Indian and global citizens do, thereby pressing the Government of Bhutan to accept dignified return of all willing citizens from exile.
Lastly, we wish you and your government the very best in your official tenure as a leader of the world’s largest democracy in the years ahead.
Govinda Rizal, PhD.
Lodrai Gaylegphug, Bhutan
Currently in Kyoto, Japan
Email: [email protected],
Skype: GovindaRizal
Parsuram Sharma-Luital
Melbourne Victoria Australia
Bholanath Shiwakoti
Chirang Bhutan
Currently in Arora, Colorado, USA
Narayan Sharma
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
DP Basnet
Alexandria, Virginia, USA
Narad Adhikari
Springfield, Massachusetts, USA
Mohan Bhandari
Roanoke, Virginia, USA
Devendra Gautam
Chirang, Bhutan
Currently in Sydney, NSW, Autralia
Upendra Dahal
Gelephu, Bhutan
Currently in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA
Mohan Tamang
California, USA
Hari Subedi
Albquerque, New Mexico, USA
Tara Dhungana
Ohio, USA
Sushil Niroula
South Australia (Adelaide), Australia
Rudra Kuikel
Samdrup Jongkhar, Bhutan
Currently in Salt Lake City, Utah, USA
Tikaram Adhikari
Chirang, Bhutan
Currently in Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada.
CB Dahal
Northland, Wellington, New Zealand
KB Chauhan
Former Assembly Member,
Dagapela, Bhutan
Currently in Arizona, USA
Y.P Dhungel
Sydney, NSW, Australia
Thugten Dorjee Drukpa,
Horsens Denmark
T B Gurung
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA
Padam Rizal
Harrisburg Pennsylvania, USA
Ram BK Chhetri
The Hague, The Netherlands
Kuber Poudel Chhetri
Dalim-Bhangtar, Bhutan
Currently in Las Vegas, NV
Tulashi Upreti
Chirang, Bhutan
Current in Lexington, Kentucky, USA
Hundreds of refugees resettled in Salt Lake City, Utah from 27 different countries around world joined the World Refugee Day Celebration Organized in Liberty Park located in heart of the capital township of Utah with different cultural dances, sports, foods, clothes and many items of traditional identity and important, on June 7.
Speaking at the program, Governor Gary Herbert, said, “Refugees are the victims of persecution, fear and need to feel Utah their home. We are proud that these people are already involved in the economic growth of the state.”
Bhutanese artist presents traditional Maruni dance (Picture: Khem Kafley/BNS)
The officer from the office of immigration administered oath of allegiance to 23 recently naturalized US citizens including 7 Bhutanese who had recently completed naturalization process from this state.
Refugee Office Director of the Department Workforce Services, Gerald Brown, handed awards to the resettlement agency head of the International Rescue Committee, Catholic Community Services and Asian Association of Utah for their instrumental contribution in facilitating the integration of refugee communities towards the mainstream society as community partners.
Unlike past years, this time many Bhutanese were seen selling foods and other household items as many other refugee communities do, during the refugee festival.
The celebration looked like a mini fair. More than 20 stalls were busy selling their programs, foods, clothes and other cultural items from local and abroad.
Deb Coffey, the event coordinator, speaking to BNS, said, “This event of refugees and mainstream communities is to support one another and to celebrate diversities and cultures.”
As a part of refugee month celebration, the refugee office also organized soccer league matches. As per the team captain, Hari Subba, the Bhutanese team played up to semi-final this year.
The program was coordinated by the Office of Refugee Services, Work Force Services in collaboration with the International Rescue Committee, Catholic Community Services and Asian Association of Utah, refugee resettlement agencies, Salt Lake County, Refugee Communities and Local communities.
The MC, Big Budah, Fox 13 reporter, remained attraction of the program throughout the ceremony.
After a bout of suicides taking toll in the resettled Bhutanese community, there has been a talk about how the escalating rate of suicide could be prevented with the increasing role of community organizations and volunteers. In the process of seeking success stories as an attempt to ameliorate the trend, Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR) has begun to document the success stories within the community as motivational campaign to stop further suicides. An onsite filming of the video took place in Philadelphia to begin with the project. In an email response to the questions sent to Bhutan News Service, ORR, Administration for Children and Families, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, clarified more about the project. Here are the excerpts:
Despite some sporadic efforts to prevent suicide, it is rising. Why does ORR consider videos as another alternative to the solution?
The video project is one resource among many that ORR and others are using to promote emotional wellness and suicide prevention. Since we started the project we have heard of other community organizations who are using stories to communicate a message of hope and wellness.
Let’s stop suicide: A thematic poster on suicide prevention circulated by BNS in collaboration with artist Kiren Pele, Rochester, NY
Can ORR explains how this project will go about? What stories are expected to be represented in the video project?
The stories will be representative of the community and include younger, middle aged and older members, both males and females, and people from different social groups.
What kind of success stories from other communities will help to build hope and resilience in the Bhutanese community? Will the project include such stories?
There are certainly many stories from other refugee communities that inspire hope. However, for this project we decided to focus on stories within the Bhutanese community.
What media does ORR think shall be more effective in reaching the videos to a likely target family or a vulnerable individual?
Any national broadcasters to carry this message? We are working primarily with Bhutanese community-based organizations and service providers working with Bhutanese refugees to spread the word. In addition, organizations such as the Bhutan News Service will be a great help in reaching the target audience.
How long has ORR considered this video project and who are the partners in this project?
ORR started planning for a video to address emotional wellness and suicide prevention in the fall of 2013. Partner organizations include several Bhutanese community based organizations around the U.S., in particular the Bhutanese American Organization of Philadelphia, which host the on-site filming portion. Other partner organizations include Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA), Pathways to Wellness, and the Harvard Program in Refugee Trauma,
What are the expectations as an outcome of sharing hope stories through video? And what time frame?
The video will be finalized by the fall of 2014 and will be made available for community-based organizations, resettlement agencies, and other service providers to share with Bhutanese refugees. The expectation is that by listening to stories of other people who have overcome emotionally difficult experiences, vulnerable individuals will be encouraged to persevere and maintain a sense of hope.
The Maryland Bhutanese team won the trophy of the two-day interstate soccer tournament organized by Bhutanese Youth Association of Charlotte (BYAC) at the University of North Carolina at Charlotte’s playground, Sunday.
The Maryland team enjoys its victory at UNCC, Sunday
The Maryland team secured its victory in the final battle against the Richmond FC United team scoring 3-2 during the penalty shootout, according to the organizers.
Maryland and Richmond United received cash prize of US $1200 and US $900 each.
Due to time constraint, the final was played seven and a half minutes each with one-minute break.
Georgia and Greensboro were ousted during semi-finals allowing their opponents, Maryland and Richmond respectively, into the finale.
Altogether seventeen soccer teams played the knockout tournament. Bhutanese referees Jitu Basnet, Khara Basnet, Burna Khawas and Billa Rai monitored games.
He spent his childhood in a refugee camp Nepal. But six years ago, Devi Charan Chamlagain came to Norway. This week, he completed studies at the University of Alta – with top grades.
Devi Chamlagai. Photo: Kristian Bye / NRK
Devi Charan Chamlagai spent most of the childhood in a refugee camp in Nepal. He and his family had to move from the small kingdom of Bhutan, at the foot of the Himalayas because of religious affiliation.
“When I went to school in Nepal, I did pretty well, and I thought I had to try to get good grades here too. But getting A is not easy. So when I did it, I thought that my dream finally came true”, says Devi Charan Chamlagai.
It is A he stands with, both in written and oral exams, taking a bachelor’s degree in Social Work at the university’s department of Alta.
And this after only six years in Norway! He came to a country without knowing a single word of the language, and certainly didn’t feel comfortable with the climate.
But help from friends, teachers and family helped him take higher education.
Had to start it again
Chamlagai was resettled in Alta in 2008 under third country resettlement scheme.
Although Devi worked as a teacher while he stayed in Nepal, he had to start all over again when he and his family came to Norway in 2008.
“I thought: Do I have to start all over again? Am I a child? I wanted to get into the job market, buy a house and a car and live a normal life”, he says.
But the Bhutanese started studying again although it was difficult. The Norwegian language with their distinctive sounds was difficult. But thanks to his mother’s efforts, so that he could move further.
And he threw himself into what he was determined to.
“I like to be outside with friends. When you’re out and in activities, you learn the language better”, he says enthusiastically.
Learned the content three times
Devi’s teacher, Nina Hermansen, says she is impressed by what he has achieved.
“Remember that he has acquired the content by translating it into his own language, then to English and then back to the Norwegian again. So, we can well say that he has learned curriculum three times”, she said.
“Besides this, he was very good at asking questions”, she said.
And even Devi believes that one must not be afraid to ask questions.
“I kept thinking that if I try, I manage it. And so I ask”, he says.
Now Devi likes to help others who come as strangers to Norway.
“And then I think that strangers should be integrated, not only assimilated,” he said.
And the refugee is clear about one thing:
“We need to help the new country of ours. Here we have security, that we must participate in the community”, he said.
(The feature which was firstcarriedbyNRK(an abbreviation of the Norwegian: Norsk rikskringkasting AS which is expressed as the Norwegian Broadcasting Corporation in English) has been translated into English from Norwegian with the permission of NRK by Ramesh Gautam.)
I am one of the seven siblings born to my parents in Lapsibotay, Chirang district in 1932. Of the four brothers, three are living: the eldest one, now 91 years, is resettled in Virginia. I was born and brought up in a farmland, simply doing the chores required to keep the family farm attended. My parents arranged by marriage at the age of seven years, and I became the boss of my wife.
I was not sent to school, and there was none at the time. A Sanskrit pathsala established in Lamidara, by the community effort was imparting the traditional learning of religious books in Sanskrit.
English was then considered alien language to learn; branded as the language of ‘beef-eaters’. Later, a community school was opened in Damphu where I was sent for few months at the age of 14.
One day when I was just walking down the path from Damphu, I caught up with some government people, I guess, looking for youths like me to recruit to the police and armed force of Bhutan.
Without offering me any chance to inform my family, they took me to Sarbhangtaar. There was the training center and I was now a recruit to the army. During the training, I had to take the food making the edge of my kameez the plate and mug.
I got my supply of clothes and utensils only after a month. By then, my top-knot (tuppi) was gone,and I was considered downgraded from my caste. The small piece of loincloth (dhoti/lagauti) that I used to have did not serve well to cover the private parts.
After six months of simple training, our group of cadres was sent to road construction in Surey-Samkhara. The place was also called Hattikhola, then.
The sacred thread, Janai, that I offered at Shivalaya, the temple, could be worn again only by performing the consecration ritual upon returning from the army. The purpose was to regain the original sanctity of a family life I am supposed to live.
I had once worked as an assistant to the headman (Mandal). It was the time of many development works taking place in Bhutan–road construction, schools, bridges, government offices and irrigation channels etc. The official command came as and when required. So, we the local officers in villages had to run even at night to look for people who should go to the work force, without considering their own ability to contribute.
A page from the book of Land Act 1977 in Nepali, indicating that Nepali was essentially means of communication for official purpose too
Chirangdara school was built with such voluntary labor contribution by village people, carrying the construction materials uphill from Damphu. But it was the development people wanted; all of us wanted to send our children to schools nearby. School in Damphu had been started; that it was not initially taken up by the government. It began as small mud house constructed around 1940 in Damphu bazar. People who sent their children to the school had to register the names with a donation of one maana (around half kilogram) of rice and one Rupee. Lingden sir from Kaleboong ( Kalimpong) came to teach Nepali and English and he took charge of expanding the school. He was acting headmaster of the school running from nursery to grade five.
Life was primitive in those days and it was a living in paucity. There were few things to buy and sell, only essential commodities like salt, kerosene, clothes, soap, sugar and spices. Chanchey Bazar was the only weekly market where we used to buy goods. Few merchants like Setu Basnet sold clothes, no not ready made ones. Even school uniforms were tailored with hands. For getting the supplies in larger quantity as reserve for the rainy seasons, or get more valuable household items, we had to come down to Sarbhang. Everything of the shopping bounty carried on horse back, few kilograms shared by men too. The currency used was 0.50 denomination silver coins, usually called Peta. Indian currency was very much common in the border markets but not in the interior.
Land for settlement was aplenty. You could easily acquire virgin land with simple registration procedure at the local office of Sub-divisional head or even with the village head (the Mandal). A few kilograms of butter or chilli or may be milk and cheese could make the official happy enough to register land in a person’s name. Such land was called Chaardamey.
Tax was levied on all kinds of property owned. I payed land tax of 18 rupees equivalent of Indian currency, while for a cow was 1.25 rupees, and that for a buffalo 2.50 rupees. Difference in land tax for wetland and dry land came in force with enforcement of land act.
The prime minister Jigme Palden Dorji (aka Kumar Sahib) used to come to Damphu and encourage us to show patriotism, to be loyal to the king and country. He often sang a patriotic song in Nepali and encouraged everyone to sing. I guess, if he was not assassinated, we would not have met this fate. He was very kind and caring to all southern population.
Wakhleytar in Wangdi-Chirang road is still the name secured after my second brother’s prosperous establishment. The only hotel he owned served repast for all passengers who commute along that road, connecting Chirang with Thimphu. The bridge over Sunkosh was often named as Wakhleypool.
One interesting occasion I lived through was an accidental meeting with the third King Jigme Dorji Wangchuk. I had been to Wangdi to sell tobacco where we had chance to see him in the dzong. Upon returning, we ran out of food supply we carried. There was no way to buy food at the time; we could only get few kilograms of rice or some potatoes. I went out to a village (the drukpa village) where I acted as a magical saint to seek alms with chanting of esoteric hymns that I learned by heart. I was offered plenty: rice, chillies, butter, cheese and potatoes. The supply lasted for the journey on foot back home to Chirang.
I usually dream about my life in Bhutan. There was no such intention to leave the country, but circumstances forced my family. My second eldest son, who still lives in Bhutan, wanted to defer our form/application to move out of the country. Being a senior civil servant in department of power, he ran from one office to another, using his bureaucratic influence to stop the voluntary migration form we filled out. All was in vain. He was taken under an undeclared confinement, limiting his movement, until we were compelled to leave the home. He was later coerced, restricting him for promotion or even work in his duty, but simply giving him some allowance at home.
Resettlement in the US has offered us a better physical living, but not spiritually satisfying. Life in the camps was not at all productive, nothing good to remember about.
Here I am, learning English at the elderly day care center, learning the history of US so as to pass the citizenship test. But, effort to learn a new language at this age is a herculean task. Whatever I learn in the day care is too volatile; it goes off as I reach home.
(As narrated to Buddha Mani Dhakal of BNS at Wagle’s residence, a house owned by his youngest son, Bal Bahadur Wakhley, in Louisville, Kentucky)
Unlike what many regional think tanks have speculated that the new Indian Prime Minister, Narendra Modi, would visit either Pakistan or Sri Lank, he is set to visit Bhutan later this month as his first state visit.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi shake hands with his Bhutan counterpart Tshering Tobgay during a meeting at Hyderabad House in New Delhi (Picture courtesy: PTI)
An official team will be off to Bhutan on Friday to set up the visit and work out the logistics, reported Times of India (ToI), Thursday.
According to the report, the decision was taken over the past few days during which Modi’s tour calendar was being finalized. The discussion also touched choices among Nepal, Bangladesh and Afghanistan.
The any government unit from Bhutan has reported about Modi’s visit as of now.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi shake hands with his Bhutan counterpart Lyonchhen Tshering Tobgay during a meeting at Hyderabad House in New Delhi on Tuesday.
Bishnu Bhandari, who was resettled by the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) in 2010 when she was 99, passed away in Glendale, Arizona, on May 27. She was 103.
She could be the eldest resettled Bhutanese to end life in diaspora.
Born in 1911 in Lamidanda, she was married to late Sunman Bhandari when she was just seven. Her husband died at the age of 82 in 1988.
Late Bishnu Bhandari (Picture courtesy: Prem Bhandari)
At the age of 81, Bhandari was forced to take refuge in Nepal. She arrived in Nepal with Prem Bhandari, the only living son among five her five sons, in 1992.
Late Bhandari arrived in Arizona on March 4, 2010 through the federally funded third country resettlement program.
In the U.S., she became a special guest to several community events and celebrations. According to her family, Bishnu spent final stage of her life in watching televisions and talking with kids.
“She was an amazing lady,” recalled one of her relatives. “If someone greeted her over phone by saying hello, she would say kodalo.”
Former National Assembly member, K.B. Chouhan, who last visited Bishnu in her residence a few days before she passed away, commented that it was one of the rarest visits to see someone, who has survived a century-long history of a country.
“She was lying unconscious on her bed. She was a vivid example of motherly love,” said he.
She is survived by her son Prem, two daughters namely Dil Maya Dhital and Hari Maya Sherpa, 27 grandchildren, 38 great-grandchildren and Ganga Bhandari, Bishnu’s adopted son.
Funeral service was conducted at 8:30 AM at 4141 N 19th Ave, Phoenix, AZ 85015 on June 2.